I would go with the cheapest for sure! Go here: and I assure you that you will find something great and cheap.

Maui is fun and exciting, but more of a place to see pretty than have a party. The water is rough and deep, so there isn’t a lot of snorkeling… which I like to do. Think of Maui as a place to go and relax. Sandals in Negril is pretty, and though you are far from a lot of the excitement in Jamaica, you will have a guaranteed good time there. It’s kind of dangerous out there though, I wouldn’t stray from from the resort without a tour group. The resort sits right next to Hedonism, and from my experience, the people at Hedonism were having a better time if you want my opinion. If i go back, I’ll probably stay there. I haven’t been to Antigua, so I can’t offer advice. I do live in South Florida, however, and I can’t think of a better place to live or play. Unfortunately, we aren’t all inclusive, and I get the idea that’s what you’re looking for. No matter where you go, you’ll have a blast!